Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island, NY Fishing Guide

Species at Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island

• Striped Bass

  Spring/fall migration; feeds hard on moving water 50-68F

  Season: Apr–Jun, Oct–Dec · Tide: moving water · Light: low light · Water: 50–68°F

• Bluefish

  55F triggers gator blitzes on bait in spring and fall

  Season: May–Jun, Sep–Nov · Tide: moving water · Light: any light · Water: 55–72°F

• Summer Flounder (Fluke)

  Ambushes bait swept through inlets on current; 68F sweet spot

  Season: May–Sep · Tide: moving water · Light: bright daylight · Water: 58–75°F

• Weakfish

  Spring spawn run; bites near 60F at first light on outgoing

  Season: May–Jun, Sep–Oct · Tide: the outgoing tide · Light: low light · Water: 58–68°F

• Tautog (Blackfish)

  Cooling water packs tog on structure; bite best near slack

  Season: Apr, Oct–Dec · Tide: slack water · Light: bright daylight · Water: 45–58°F

• Black Drum

  Big spawners flood Delaware Bay at dusk on max current

  Season: Apr–Jun · Tide: moving water · Light: low light · Water: 55–68°F

• Red Drum (Redfish)

  Bull schools roam lower-bay shoals; bite from 58-60F up

  Season: May–Jun, Sep–Oct · Tide: moving water · Light: any light · Water: 58–78°F

• Sheepshead

  Picks crabs off pilings as water warms past mid-60s

  Season: Jun–Oct · Tide: moving water · Light: bright daylight · Water: 65–80°F

• Spotted Seatrout (Specks)

  Roams grass and creek mouths; fall bite peaks as bait stages

  Season: May–Jun, Sep–Nov · Tide: moving water · Light: low light · Water: 60–80°F

• Black Sea Bass

  Stacks on inshore structure in spring and pre-migration fall

  Season: May–Jun, Sep–Nov · Tide: slack water · Light: bright daylight · Water: 48–68°F

• Scup (Porgy)

  Schools inshore over structure once water clears mid-50s

  Season: Jun–Oct · Tide: moving water · Light: bright daylight · Water: 55–77°F

• Northern Kingfish

  Summer's warmest water pulls kings into surf and bay sloughs

  Season: Jun–Sep · Tide: moving water · Light: any light · Water: 68–80°F

• Atlantic Croaker

  Bottom-feeds bay flats and channels through warm months

  Season: Jun–Oct · Tide: moving water · Light: low light · Water: 60–78°F

• False Albacore (Albie)

  Cooling 72-to-64F bait migration sparks blitzing albies

  Season: Sep–Oct · Tide: moving water · Light: any light · Water: 64–72°F

What's biting at Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island, month by month

Typical seasons for this stretch of coast — a warm or late year shifts them by a few weeks. The live forecast scores today's actual conditions.

Coastal runs that pass Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island

These species travel the coast with the seasons, so they show up on a schedule rather than living here year-round.

• Striped bass

  the fall run south is the event of the year — the most reliable cascade signal in the NE

  Timing: northbound Mar–Jun · southbound Sep–Nov · Driven by: water temp (55–68°F); follows bunker & sand eels · Pace: ~50–100 mi/week along the surf; ~1,000 mi in 6–8 wks

• Bluefish

  blitzes alongside the stripers

  Timing: northbound Apr–Jun · southbound Sep–Nov · Driven by: temp + bunker/herring · Pace: fast, tracking the bait

• Weakfish

  stock is depleted — a historic cascade that reports rarely light up now

  Timing: northbound Mar–Jun · southbound Sep–Nov · Driven by: warming water; bunker, silversides, shrimp · Pace: moderate; into the bays ahead of summer heat

• Bonito

  Atlantic bonito — erratic year to year; NC spring blitz + NE summer

  Timing: northbound Apr–Jun · southbound Sep–Oct · Driven by: sand eels, anchovies, butterfish · Pace: moderate; often just ahead of the albies

• False albacore

  false albacore — fall cascade Nantucket→Cape Cod→NJ→NC; the Cape Lookout run is famous

  Timing: southbound Aug–Nov · northbound Apr–May · Driven by: temp (75–86°F); bay anchovies, silversides · Pace: very fast — NC→Keys in ~23 days, ~50 mi/day

• Spot

  Chesapeake/VA panfish + a fall bait; keyword collides with generic "spot" — needs phrase context

  Timing: northbound Apr–May · southbound Sep–Nov · Driven by: temp; tidal creeks · Pace: big fall schools through the inlets

• Redfish (red drum)

  bull-red fall surf run cascades by latitude: Mid-Atl Sep–Oct → FL Oct–Nov → Gulf Nov–Dec

  Timing: southbound Sep–Nov · Driven by: falling temps trigger the nearshore spawn run · Pace: cold-front-latency tide more than fish-following-fish

• Cobia

  SE-Atlantic stock — winters off S.FL/Keys, sight-fishing run up the beach; no clean fall cascade (disperses offshore)

  Timing: northbound Mar–Jun · Driven by: warming water; rides with cownose rays & bunker, near the surface · Pace: ~6-wk spring run; arrives NC May–Jun, Chesapeake late May

• Spanish mackerel

  Atlantic stock — strong cascade up the SE coast in spring

  Timing: northbound Feb–Jun · southbound Sep–Nov · Driven by: glass minnows & scaled sardines · Pace: tracks the 68–70°F water; ~2–3 wk lag SC→NC

• Mullet bait run

  the fall mullet run — the stripers & blues pile on it

  Timing: southbound Sep–Nov · Driven by: falling temps + photoperiod · Pace: the famous fall mullet run, S down the FL east coast; peak Sep–Oct

• Bunker (menhaden) bait run

  bunker/pogies — the stripers & blues are right under them

  Timing: northbound Mar–Jun · southbound Sep–Nov · Driven by: temp + plankton blooms · Pace: huge schools shift the coast; the #1 trigger for the fall striper/blues blitz

How Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island fishes

Open water lies to the east of Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island. A wind out of the east is onshore here — it stacks swell and chop into the mouth and pushes stirred-up water inshore, while a west wind flattens the surface and tends to clean it up.

Tide is the clock: moving water pulls bait through the mouth, and the turns around slack are when most of the roster feeds hardest.

Tides here are read from NOAA station 8511236 at 41.1717, -72.2050 — see it on NOAA CO-OPS.

Shops & partners near Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island

Across New York:

• 📦 Great Bay Outfitters

  Fishing kayaks, trolling motors and boat rigging, with kayak delivery across the Northeast.

We point you at people who put in the on-the-water work. Anything we're paid for says Partner.

Common questions about Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island

What fish can you catch at Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island?

Striped Bass, Bluefish, Summer Flounder (Fluke), Weakfish, Tautog (Blackfish), Black Drum, Red Drum (Redfish), Sheepshead, Spotted Seatrout (Specks), Black Sea Bass, Scup (Porgy), Northern Kingfish and 2 more. Each has its own season, preferred tide and water-temperature window at Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island.

When is the best time to fish Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island?

June has the most species in season (12 of 14) — Striped Bass, Bluefish, Summer Flounder (Fluke), Weakfish, Black Drum, Red Drum (Redfish), Sheepshead, Spotted Seatrout (Specks). Seasons shift by a few weeks in a warm or late year.

Is there anything biting at Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island in winter?

January, February, March are the quiet stretch — none of the species we track are in their window then. The bite picks back up in April.

What tide is best for fishing Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island?

11 of the 14 species here feed best on moving water. Moving water is what pulls bait through the mouth, so the hours either side of a tide change usually beat dead slack.

Which wind is bad for Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island?

Open water lies to the east, so an east wind is onshore — it stacks swell and chop into the mouth and pushes dirty water inshore. A west wind flattens and cleans it up.

Do migrating fish run past Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island?

Yes — Striped bass (northbound Mar–Jun · southbound Sep–Nov); Bluefish (northbound Apr–Jun · southbound Sep–Nov); Weakfish (northbound Mar–Jun · southbound Sep–Nov); Bonito (northbound Apr–Jun · southbound Sep–Oct); False albacore (southbound Aug–Nov · northbound Apr–May); Spot (northbound Apr–May · southbound Sep–Nov). These travel the coast with the seasons rather than living here year-round.

Where are the tides for Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island measured?

NOAA CO-OPS station 8511236, at 41.1717, -72.2050. What Inlet? scores the live tide, current, solunar and weather for that station.

Inlets near Plum Gut Harbor, Plum Island

• Threemile Harbor entrance, Gardiners Bay 9 mi
• Saybrook Jetty 10 mi
• Sag Harbor 13 mi
• Noyack Bay 14 mi
• Montauk, Fort Pond Bay 15 mi
• Montauk Harbor entrance 15 mi
• Clinton Harbor 18 mi
• Mattituck Inlet 22 mi

Fishing a different inlet today? Every one has its own species roster and bite pattern.

Browse every inlet in New York, or the full inlet directory.